BELOIT — As Stateline-area farmers set out to plant
their fields this spring, they find themselves part
of a global debate about how their major crop — corn
— is used.
More than 20 percent of American corn now is diverted
from the food supply to the ethanol industry to keep
up with government food-to-fuel mandates. That has
created record-high prices for farmers (see related
graphic), but also price pressures on food — exacerbated
by the high cost of gasoline — that have reverberated
around the world.
“There’s no question that the idea of using corn
for ethanol has benefited farmers in Wisconsin,”
said Jim Miller, president of the Wisconsin Policy
Research Institute, which supports free markets.
“(But) what does it do to the rest of the world in
terms of prices of food?”
In some cases, it has contributed to food shortages
and public unrest in Africa and Haiti. At home, ethanol
production and higher transportation costs have produced
a sharp spike in grocery prices. In a USA Today/Gallup
poll released Tuesday, nearly half of those responding
said food inflation has caused a hardship for their
households.
“There’s no question that food prices are going
up on everything,” Miller said. “(And) when it affects
prices here, it’s going to affect prices in the rest
of the world.”
Beloit College professor Marion Fass, who has taught
a course on food issues, agrees.
“Part of the problem recently is that prices have
gone up for corn (due to) ethanol, and then prices
have gone up for tortillas in Mexico,” Foss said.
“I think part of the problem is that we started looking
at ethanol as a solution to our energy problems without
thinking about the consequences.”
For crop farmers, however, these are the salad days,
with recent record yields and record-high prices
ensuring substantial profits.
“They’re itching to go,” said Jim Stute, crops and
soils agent with the University of Wisconsin Rock
County Extension office. “They’re at the starting
gate, pushing at the block, just waiting to get out
there (and plant their fields).”
In Wisconsin, farmers are planting 10 percent less
corn this year, because it costs more to raise, and
also because demand for corn has produced higher
prices for other lower-maintenance crops like wheat
and soybeans. Still, the total acreage devoted to
corn remains larger than in the past.
“Wheat and corn have kind of led the way in commodities,”
said Jason Henschler, a Turtle Township grain farmer
who plants corn, soybeans and winter wheat on his
1,500 acres. “Prices are definitely at record levels,
as far as I’ve seen.”
Though corn production will be down, said Casey
Langan of the Wisconsin Farm Bureau Federation, the
harvest will “still be the second-largest corn crop
that we’ve ever had.”
Henschler’s farm reflects that trend.
“Last year, we were probably 80 percent corn,” he
said. “We’ll probably back that off to 70 percent.
In the past, we used to be 50-50, probably, corn
and soybeans, but we’ve increased our corn over the
last two years because of the price.”
Henschler and other farmers say increased costs
influenced their decision to plant slightly less
corn this year.
“Even though the corn price has doubled, our input
cost has also doubled — fuel, fertilizer, feed,”
he said. “The high commodity prices are a good thing,
but we need to have them that high to break even.”
Clinton grain farmer Gary Sommers agreed.
“So far, the prices are good, but input costs have
gone up substantially from last year, too,” Sommers
said.
In Illinois, Winnebago County Farm Bureau Manager
Roger Christin is seeing similar developments.
“We’re seeing probably a little less corn, as the
price of soybeans has increased,” he said, “(But
corn) is still the farmer’s favorite crop.”
Miller noted that continued corn production for
ethanol will put additional pressure on food prices
worldwide, and further stoke the food-for-fuel debate.
“Somewhere in there,” he said, “there has to be
a happy medium.”
Langan, of the Wisconsin Farm Bureau Federation,
noted that the ethanol industry’s appetite for corn
is but one factor affecting the increase in food
prices. Higher transportation costs also have a significant
impact, he said.
“While ethanol definitely has an impact on the price
of corn, it’s not the sole driver of it,” Langan
said.
Christin agreed.
“People think it’s all going to ethanol, and it’s
not,” he said.
He added that demand for United States grain exports
is up because the value of the dollar is down, and
that some investors treading water in a bearish stock
market have turned their attention to commodities,
where speculation has helped drive price increases.
In addition to the corn diverted to the ethanol
industry, Langan said, some 20 percent to 25 percent
of the domestic crop is exported to countries like
China and Brazil, which have expanding middle classes.
“(And) just because it goes into ethanol, it doesn’t
mean it’s not in the food chain,” he said. “Some
of the corn used for ethanol does work its way into
the food chain.”
That corn byproduct, left over from the ethanol-production
process, increasingly is used by livestock farmers
who have seen corn-based feed costs spike over the
past couple of years (see related story).
While debate over corn and ethanol production rages,
farmers continue to keep an eye on the cold, wet
ground. Those who will plant large amounts of corn
want to do so as soon as possible. Though they are
not behind schedule, they are approaching the ideal
planting date of May 1.
“May 1 is the optimum planting date for corn in
southern Wisconsin,” Stute said. “(But) there’s still
standing water in some fields.”
Christin said that in Winnebago County, seeds are
being sewn.
“We’re seeing a few planters moving now, but the
ground’s a little on the chilly side,” he said. “Farmers
traditionally like to get it in as soon as they can.
The better yields come the earlier that we plant
it.”
If farmers have to wait too long to plant corn,
they might convert to soybean production, Stute said.
That could further restrict supplies of corn intended
for the food supply.
“Soybeans aren’t as sensitive to planting dates
in terms of yield,” he said.